To answer a pretty open-ended question, let's tackle the fundamentals of developing software securely. Optimally, start at the architecture phase, with a threat model that tries to anticipate the most predictable attack vectors on the software. With that threat model, it's possible to design defenses in to address those attack vectors, then constantly check the code and test the ability to defend the private data.
Of course, that utopia tends not to exist in the real world, as most security professionals inherit an application or a software package and have to make the best of it. That's where gap analysis comes in. Basically this involves figuring out where the gaps exist in existing defenses and then putting a plan in place to address the issues.
How can that be done with existing code? There are three main ways and all are important. So to be clear right up front, the answer isn't either/or, it's to what degree all three techniques should be used:
- Automated testing -- Look at application scanners, which analyze source code and check for common errors that can create exposures; things like SQL injection, faulty input validation and cross-site scripting can be reasonably easy to pinpoint.
- Pen testing -- As good as many of the application scanners are, there is no substitute for a real person trying to figure out how an application can be exploited. In many cases, a penetration tester can find logic errors that are highly problematic yet can't be caught by scanners.
- Code reviews -- The third technique is to actually look through the code and find problems. Yes, this can be time consuming, but it's important. Again, there are things that a good code review will pinpoint that will be missed by the other methods.
So yes, a gap analysis does have a place in developing software securely, though more often when retro-fitting an existing application.
- Watch this interview with Gary McGraw, who discusses secure software development.
- Read more about analyzing business processes and infrastructure for data protection.
Dig deeper on Software Development Methodology
Related Q&A from Mike Rothman, Contributor
In the world of security certifications, what is the GISP and how alike is it to the CISSP? In this security management expert response, learn about ...continue reading
Depending on your enterprise, it may or may not be necessary to utilize a QSA. In this security management expert response, learn how to determine ...continue reading
Security appliances range widely in cost and capability, so what's the best way to decide the right appliance for your enterprise? In this security ...continue reading
Have a question for an expert?
Please add a title for your question
Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.