GOLD | Cisco VPN 3000 Series Concentrator
Cisco Systems
Price: $2,995-$45,000
Cisco's VPN 3000 Series Concentrator continues to lead the secure remote access market, not only in the number of products shipped but
Requires Free Membership to View
SearchSecurity.com members gain immediate and unlimited access to breaking industry news, virus alerts, new hacker threats, highly focused security newsletters, and more -- all at no cost. Join me on SearchSecurity.com today!
Michael S. Mimoso, Editorial Director
also in customer satisfaction. "Cisco has become like IBM used to be in the computer industry--its products are viewed as the best choice because users know the company's future is rock solid," says Zeus Kerravala, vice president for enterprise computing and networking at the Yankee Group.
Cisco scored well with readers in four areas--authentication support; end user transparency and ease of use; investment ROI; and extensibility.
Authentication support has become an important issue in securing transactions, and warding off identity spoofing. "Cisco has been one of the companies leading movement to NAC (Network Access Control), which promises to make it easier for enterprises to authenticate remote users," says Pete Lindstrom, a senior analyst, Burton Group. NAC authenticates and checks on the health of systems as they attempt to connect to a corporate network.
One challenge for security administrators is deploying products that keep a company's data safe without hindering users' ability to function. The Cisco VPN 3000 Series Concentrator works with a variety of applications through its SSL VPN client.
In addition, the company has done a good job in making its system easy to deploy. Its integrated, Web-based management system provides an interface for configuring and monitoring remote users. For remote access and site-to-site VPNs, ease of deployment is critical because technical personnel are often not available to configure the secure connections at remote sites. Cisco's Easy VPN solution pushes security policies to remote VPN devices, helping ensure that up-to-date policies are in place before a connection is established.
Readers gave Cisco high marks for ROI. Since it is the leading networking company, Cisco can spread its operating costs over a large customer base and lower product pricing. The Concentrator platform does not add licensing costs for special features, such as a multidevice clustering that allows the remote access solution to scale as a business grows. Since both SSL and IPsec VPNs are available on one platform, customers can deploy parallel remote access infrastructures.
As the leading networking supplier, Cisco has garnered a stellar reputation for delivering products that meet customer needs. That success has migrated from its network equipment to its remote access security products.
SILVER | Citrix Access Gateway
Citrix
Price: $3,500-$50,000
Citrix Access Gateway simplifies and secures remote access to applications. The Access Gateway delivers the same desktop access experience users have within the network, removing the need for additional training. In addition, it automatically reconnects users to their applications and documents when they change locations or devices. Citrix also has an extensible product line--the Access Gateway provides secure access to Windows and UNIX applications, Web applications, Citrix Presentation Server-hosted applications, network file shares and telephony services using VoIP softphones. No application customization is required to use these features.
BRONZE | Check Point VPN-1
Check Point Software Technologies
Price: $3,000
Readers noted Check Point VPN-1's extensibility. VPN-1 works on Windows, Windows Mobile and Macintosh platforms. In addition, the client software supports dynamic and fixed IP addressing for dial-up, cable modem or DSL connections. This flexibility enables telecommuters and mobile workers to access their company networks via an Internet Service Provider, wireless hotspot or hotel Internet access connection. Authentication support was a second strong point.
VPN-1 also supports SmartDefense Services, which provides real-time updates and security configuration advisories.
This was first published in April 2007