Less than two years after being hired by Symantec Corp., CEO Steve Bennett was ousted by the security giant's board...
By submitting your personal information, you agree that TechTarget and its partners may contact you regarding relevant content, products and special offers.
Thursday, but according to industry observers familiar with Symantec, its struggles to define and execute a security product strategy go far deeper than any one executive.
They don't know who they are, they don't know what they want to do, and that's infiltrating all the way through their organization.
CEO, Rook Security
Much of Bennett's time at Big Yellow was spent implementing what he termed the Symantec 4.0 strategy, which mostly focused on paring back products, services and staff. Though Symantec's stock price more than doubled during his first year, Bennett was unable to maintain that momentum; the stock price has dipped 15% in the past year. Similarly, sales of Symantec's line of consumer products, headlined by its Norton-branded endpoint antimalware technology, declined 2.8% in 2013, a foreboding statistic considering how closely linked the company's brand is with traditional endpoint security.
Chris Rodriguez, network security senior industry analyst at San Antonio, Texas-based consulting firm Frost & Sullivan, said that while Symantec has products in emerging security product segments, such as the high-growth mobile space, the company has struggled to compete against a myriad of upstarts. In mobile, for instance, Rodriguez said security technology from rivals Avast Software and Lookout Inc. is just as effective and often much cheaper, if not free.
'Bloated' Symantec facing deep-rooted issues
Despite those obvious headwinds, a variety of experts told SearchSecurity that the root of Symantec's issues runs much deeper than Bennett, and that much more than a new CEO will be needed to steer the company in the right direction.
Kevin McDonald, executive vice president for Irvine, Calif.-based managed IT services provider Alvaka Networks, said that the security industry has largely recognized that "Symantec was synonymous with bloated," from the company's software to its staff.
While calling the decision to fire Bennett a "mind-blower," McDonald admitted the company may not have innovated enough to stave off emerging powerhouse rivals such as FireEye Inc. that are focused on detecting advanced attacks at the network level. Still, he predicted that the next Symantec CEO would benefit greatly from the moves that Bennett made.
"I felt like there was finally stability in the company and they had somebody that knew how to look at the overall operation and make it work," McDonald said. "Bottom line is I felt like Bennett was paring back some of the bloat, and then expanding in the places he felt they needed to."
John Pescatore, director of emerging security trends at the Bethesda, Md.-based SANS Institute and the former long-time lead security analyst for Gartner Inc., said that many of the issues Bennett faced during his tenure as Symantec CEO actually had much deeper roots, going back to John W. Thompson's leadership of the company from 1999 to 2009.
Pescatore said Thompson set the tone for the company as it expanded into a variety of markets beyond information security. Pescatore noted that Microsoft's entry into the antivirus market threatened Symantec's core revenue stream. That trend continued under Bennett's predecessor, Enrique Salem, with the company soon providing everything from storage services to desktop management.
Symantec's next step: Refocus on security
Pescatore criticized Bennett for not doing enough to reverse that trend by refocusing on security. He said the company must refocus on the security market, possibly by spinning off nonsecurity products, for which it can find buyers.
While board member Michael Brown steers the ship in the interim, Pescatore encouraged Symantec not to repeat the mistake it made in appointing Bennett, formerly the CEO at financial software vendor Intuit Inc., and instead look for someone with deep ties to the security industry that can push through the transformation the company so desperately needs.
"That strategy has not worked anywhere, to try to be that sort of broad department store instead of focusing on security, and really, Bennett hadn't made any major changes there," Pescatore said. "If they don't change that strategy and they just keep changing CEOs, they'll just keep changing CEOs."
J.J. Thompson, CEO and managing director for Indianapolis-based risk and security services firm Rook Security, said he was a big believer in Symantec back in the mid-2000s, but that in recent years he became "disheartened" by the industry titan's lack of focus.
Thompson said that back in 2007 he discussed some of the very same issues cropping up in the wake of Bennett's ouster when Symantec was interviewing its channel partners to determine how to move the company forward. Thompson told Symantec at the time that middle management was "sucking the life out of the company," a stance he still holds.
In particular, Thompson said, the company's decision last year to shutter two of its managed security services -- firewall and endpoint protection -- was a perfect example of the "identity crisis" that has plagued Symantec for half a decade, noting that cutting professional security services and instead emphasizing enterprise licensing deals is absolutely the wrong strategy.
While Symantec has struggled internally, Thompson said other companies, such as FireEye and Palo Alto Networks, have stepped in to address the emerging opportunities in the security markets, specifically focusing on mitigating the advanced threats that often evade Symantec's signature-based antivirus products. Thompson said that as a result of its strategic foibles, his company has not sold Symantec products for years.
"They don't know who they are, they don't know what they want to do, and that's infiltrating all the way through their organization," Thompson said. "The company's trying to pass it off as a CEO problem, and it makes me furious. We can all blame the CEO for not being able to figure out how to fix this, but I think there's a more pervasive issue there."