Java security risks are well known, but could you provide some insight on the security of some of the open source Java frameworks like Struts, Hibernate, Java Enterprise Edition, etc.? Which of the frameworks is the most secure, and what can be done to harden them?
Ask the Expert!
SearchSecurity.com expert Michael Cobb is standing by to answer your questions about enterprise application security and platform security. Submit your question via email. (All questions are anonymous.)
Open-source Java frameworks offer a great way to jump-start application development as long as developers take the time to learn how to use them properly. Frameworks can boost developer productivity, but most have a steep learning curve before coders can benefit from using them. A recent report by CAST said the most popular open-source Java frameworks are Struts, Java Enterprise Edition, Hibernate and Spring. However, no framework provides instant security or a guarantee of flawless code.
In terms of which is the most secure framework, CAST looked at 496 applications with 152 million lines of code and found the biggest problem was actually that most apps were misconfigured. I'm not sure of the statistical conclusions that can be drawn from some of the other survey results, but this finding highlights the importance of training so that developers know how to properly use their chosen framework.
The planning stage of any application development should produce a set of specific security requirements such as authentication, authorization and encryption to enable the development team to choose the framework that best suits these needs. It may be that multiple frameworks are needed to support all requirements, though this can lead to difficulties in integrating different parts of an application.
Personally, I think using a good framework does lead to better coding discipline and reduces the overall bug count. The CAST report found applications built without a framework of any kind had a huge variance in quality. Other factors affecting the choice of framework include the quality of the documentation, particularly the documentation on security APIs, as they can be quite complex and obviously need to be used correctly. Another consideration is the responsiveness of the framework's user community, as this is an important source of help and support.
Hardening a framework involves changing somebody else's code, and that is always tricky. Any updates or patches they release may overwrite your changes or affect their behavior. If you feel it is important, then I would review any code that handles user input and entry points to the application. Is input validated and cleansed of any unexpected characters or values? If not, you could add your own validation and filtering functions to ensure data passed to your application is always safe.
As with any third-party code or application, you need to stay in touch with the vendor or bug list so that any security alerts are picked up. For example, researchers at Aspect Security found a flaw in the "expression language" function of the Spring framework that allows remote-code execution and could lead to the complete compromise of an application. This problem is proving tricky to patch, and current advice is to turn off the expression-language feature. Any developers unaware of these vulnerabilities are leaving their applications wide open to abuse and compromise. A member of the development team should be made responsible for following the security news for the programming languages and tools being used in an application, and knowing how to deal with alerts and critical patch releases.
A look at how to patch open source vulnerabilities
Dig Deeper on Secure software development
Related Q&A from Michael Cobb
Pirated software is still a major concern nowadays. Uncover how to prevent software piracy and protect your organization's intellectual property. Continue Reading
Shellcode is a set of instructions that executes a command in software to take control of or exploit a compromised machine. Read up on the malware ... Continue Reading
The popular port scan is a hacking tool that enables attackers to gather information about how corporate networks operate. Learn how to detect and ... Continue Reading